12 Comments
User's avatar
Green Mojave's avatar

I’ve always found the near field - far field transition in antenna design a true paradox.

Expand full comment
Hans G. Schantz's avatar

I'll be talking about the near field-far field transition at length throughout Fields and Energy, mostly in Chapter 8. If you can't wait, here's a talk about the history, physics, and wireless applications of low-frequency, long-wavelength systems that use the properties of the near field-far field transition.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3HGvJ9HtWzk

Expand full comment
ScuzzaMan's avatar

I do greatly appreciate Maxwell's style. He writes with great clarity and without excess.

"Space-time tells matter how to move; matter tells space-time how to curve." - as John Wheeler summarised Einstein.

If "space-time" is a persistent nothing, then:

"Nothing tells Matter how to move; Matter tells Nothing how to curve."

It seems to me that there is Something missing in this accounting. I am very open to the proposition that what is missing is in my apprehension of the points under discussion. Also looking forward to the next instalment.

Expand full comment
Hans G. Schantz's avatar

Parmenides (~515 BC): "Out of nothing, nothing comes." Ancient wisdom.

Expand full comment
ScuzzaMan's avatar

My great friend and mentor Doug B used to tell me:

"Nothing for nothing, everything for a reason."

He'll be tickled by this quote.

Thank you.

Expand full comment
steven lightfoot's avatar

I will read this with interest. Is this literally verbatim of what Maxwell wrote?

Expand full comment
Hans G. Schantz's avatar

Yes. Literally and verbatim, except for the figures and the comment on the modern accepted value for the speed of light.

Here's the source: https://archive.org/details/scientificpapers02maxwuoft/page/310/mode/2up

Expand full comment
steven lightfoot's avatar

Thank you. I will try to find the time to read this. One of the things that I have always struggled with in learning physics (and math) is that too often its taught as abstract ideas, without much background or historical context. If you have some context and history, its often easier to understand.

Expand full comment
Jim Nealon's avatar

One of the difficult but satisfying things was to derive answers to Maxwell's equations, in terms of real or practical items like current flow or light propagation. Abstract terms, vectors, and fields were easier to understand.

Expand full comment
Jim Healy's avatar

And History becomes people and events as opposed to dates and places

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 3, 2024
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Hans G. Schantz's avatar

That's certainly the conventional wisdom.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 3, 2024
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Hans G. Schantz's avatar

I misunderstood you.

Expand full comment